At any given moment, your brain is tracking:
- the guy you forgot to text back
- the conversation that ended “fine”… but wasn’t
- the decision you’ve been “praying about” for three weeks
- and something your wife mentioned that you absolutely should remember… but didn’t
And that’s before 9:30 AM.
You’re not tired.
You’re not undisciplined.
You’re mentally carrying a pile of unfinished things…
and your brain refuses to let any of them go.
What’s Actually Happening
Most pastors think they have a time problem.
You don’t.
You have a cognitive load problem.
An "open loop" is anything unresolved that your brain thinks still matters:
- a decision not made
- a message not answered
- a conversation not finished
- a task not defined
This is why you can walk into a room…
and immediately remember 3 things you forgot to do…
and 2 things you wish you hadn’t said.
Your brain does not politely file these away.
It keeps them active…
like 37 browser tabs open… and somehow one of them is playing music but you can’t find which one.
Why Your Brain Won’t Let This Go
There’s a well-documented phenomenon in psychology called the Zeigarnik Effect.
In simple terms:
Your brain remembers unfinished things better than finished ones.
Add to that attention residue, a concept studied by Sophie Leroy:
When you switch tasks, part of your attention stays stuck on the previous one.
So when you move from:
- a counseling conversation
→ to email
→ to a meeting
→ to sermon prep
You don’t fully arrive anywhere.
You’re partially everywhere.
Some estimates suggest knowledge workers lose 20–40% of their efficiency due to task switching and interruptions.
Translation:
You’re trying to do deep spiritual work…
with a divided mind.
Why This Hits Pastors Harder Than Most
Your role is an open loop factory.
- People problems don’t “complete”
- Conversations rarely feel fully resolved
- Decisions carry weight
- Your phone never quite stops
- Sermons are never truly “done”—just due
A businessman closes deals. A pastor carries people.
And people don’t come with a “mark as complete” button.
So your brain keeps whispering:
“Don’t forget… don’t forget… don’t forget…”
Even when you’re trying to think clearly.
The Real Cost (This Is Where It Shows Up)
This isn’t theoretical. You feel it every week.
- Shallow thinking
You skim more than you study - Sermon fog
You know the text… but clarity feels harder than it should - Decision fatigue
Simple choices feel heavier - Irritability
You’re shorter than you want to be - Low-grade mental pressure
Not panic. Just constant internal noise
Here’s the truth:
You don’t feel overwhelmed because you have too much to do.
You feel overwhelmed because too much is unresolved.
Your brain is basically a volunteer ministry team...
... well-meaning, overcommitted, and constantly reminding you of things at the wrong time.
The Shift Most Pastors Never Make
Most advice says:
“Get more done.”
That’s not your problem.
Your problem is:
Too many open loops competing for your attention
The goal is not more output.
The goal is a clear mind.
Because you cannot do deep work…
or spiritual work…
with constant internal interruption.
A Simple System to Reclaim Your Focus
This is not complicated.
But it works if you actually do it.
Step 1: Capture Everything
Get it out of your head.
- notebook
- notes app
- voice memo
- back of a church bulletin if necessary (you’ve done worse)
Rule:
If it lives in your head, it’s costing you energy.
Write down:
- tasks
- decisions
- follow-ups
- “I need to think about…” items
Immediate result:
your brain stops acting like a toddler reminding you of everything at the worst possible time.
Step 2: Clarify the Next Action
Don’t just list things—define them.
Bad:
- “Follow up with John”
Good:
- “Text John to schedule lunch Thursday”
Bad:
- “Work on sermon”
Good:
- “Outline 3 main points from Romans 8”
Ambiguity creates resistance.
Clarity creates momentum.
Step 3: Close or Contain
Every open loop must be one of four things:
- Done (if it takes less than 2 minutes, just do it)
- Scheduled (assigned to a specific time)
- Delegated
- Deferred intentionally
Key principle:
Open loops must be either closed or contained
If they’re not, they stay active in your mind.
And they keep taxing you.
How to Apply This as a Pastor
Keep it simple.
Before sermon prep (10 minutes):
- Do a quick open loop sweep
- Write everything pulling at your attention
- Clarify and park it
End of each day (5–10 minutes):
- Capture anything lingering
- Decide next actions
Once a week (20–30 minutes):
- Review everything
- Close what you can
- Schedule what remains
Final Thought
Final Thought (Alternate)
You don’t need:
- a better planner
- another app you’ll download and ignore
- or a color-coded system that makes you feel productive for 48 hours
You need:
- fewer things living rent-free in your head
Because right now, your brain is hosting a staff meeting…
with no agenda…
and everyone is talking at once.
And somehow, they all think their item is urgent.
A clear mind isn’t something that just “happens” when life slows down.
It happens when you stop carrying what you were never meant to carry all at once.
Close the loops.
Contain the rest.
And give your mind a fighting chance to do what it was actually built for:
To think clearly.
To see deeply.
And occasionally… to finish a thought without being interrupted by “Oh yeah, I forgot to…”
More Resources To Help You Optimize
💊 My (Scott's) full supplement regimen