When Optimization Makes You Worse

Have you ever felt worse after checking something that was supposed to make you healthier?

Maybe it was your sleep score.

Your recovery score.

Your step count.

You woke up feeling rested...

...until your app informed you that apparently you didn't.

Suddenly you're thinking, "Well, I thought I felt pretty good, but apparently my watch got me with a blind spot."

That raises an interesting question.

What if some optimization tools aren't actually optimizing us?

You may have noticed, I have never promoted wearables...

... even as an "optimization" guy.

There is a reason for that.

The Dashboard Became the Driver

Recently I heard a respected fitness and nutrition influencer explain why he stopped wearing both a Fitbit and an Oura Ring.

Not because they were inaccurate.

Because they were making him anxious.

He said he'd wake up feeling rested, energetic, and ready for the day.

Then he'd check his recovery score.

If the app said he'd slept poorly or his readiness was low, he'd suddenly begin questioning how he felt.

He'd start looking for evidence that he was tired.

Nothing about his body had changed.

Only the information on his screen had.

That story stuck with me because I think many of us are far more susceptible to this than we'd like to admit.

Somewhere along the way...

The dashboard became the driver.

When More Information Creates More Anxiety

I'm not anti-technology.

Far from it.

I use AI almost every day.

I automate repetitive tasks whenever I can.

I love systems.

But I've become increasingly convinced that there's a difference between tools that reduce mental clutter and tools that create it.

Every notification.

Every reminder.

Every dashboard.

Every streak.

Every score.

Every graph.

Asks for a tiny piece of your attention.

Individually, they're harmless.

Collectively, they become another job.

Apparently we needed another scoreboard besides attendance, giving, baptisms, and whether Sister Betty approved of Sunday's sermon length.

Your Brain Is Listening

There's actually a psychological principle behind this.

Most people have heard of the placebo effect.

The nocebo effect is its darker cousin.

When people expect something negative, they often begin experiencing it.

I'm not suggesting your smartwatch makes you unhealthy.

I am suggesting that it can shape your expectations.

And expectations have a funny way of coloring experience.

If your wrist tells you today is going to be rough...

You may begin living as though it already is.

When the Servant Becomes the Master

Most optimization tools begin as servants.

But if we're not careful, they become masters.

The calendar that was supposed to organize your life starts controlling it.

The task manager that was supposed to reduce stress becomes another place where unfinished work quietly judges you.

The habit tracker that was supposed to encourage consistency becomes a source of guilt because you broke your 143-day streak by forgetting to log your vitamins.

Somewhere along the way we started treating our wrist like it was the eleventh commandment.

A tool has become your master when you trust its dashboard more than your own discernment.

Pastors Already Live Under Enough Scoreboards

Pastoral ministry doesn't exactly suffer from a lack of evaluation.

Attendance.

Giving.

Baptisms.

Budget.

Meetings.

Email.

Leadership.

Family.

Preparation.

Then we gladly volunteer for even more.

Sleep scores.

VO₂ max.

Heart rate variability.

Recovery scores.

Protein grams.

Step counts.

Deep work hours.

Nothing wrong with tracking these. I often recommend it...

But if you wake up every morning to a tiny drill sergeant on your wrist telling you how you should feel today, don't be surprised if your anxiety starts marching in step.

If Apple ever adds a "How Spiritual Are You Today?" score, half of us would probably check it before reading Proverbs.

Eventually life begins to feel like one endless report card.

No wonder so many pastors carry low-grade anxiety.

Sometimes Old School Still Wins

Sometimes I wonder if we're trying to solve old problems with expensive new gadgets.

Long before wearables and health dashboards, people got healthier by doing surprisingly ordinary things.

They walked.

They lifted heavy things.

They ate real food.

They got outside.

They went to bed on time.

They rested.

None of our grandparents ever bragged about hitting a readiness score of 94.

Somehow they still managed to chop wood, raise families, and sleep just fine.

Technology can absolutely support healthy habits.

It just shouldn't replace common sense.

Ask a Better Question

Instead of asking,

"What app should I download next?"

Maybe we should ask,

"Will this reduce my mental clutter...or increase it?"

The best optimization tools quietly disappear into the background.

The worst ones keep demanding that you pay attention to them.

The best optimization tools free your attention.

The worst ones compete for it.

Optimize for Freedom

Here's the irony.

The best optimization system I've ever found isn't the one that tells me the most.

It's the one that frees me to think about myself the least.

Because the goal of optimization isn't becoming fascinated with your own metrics.

It's becoming more available to love your family.

Serve your church.

Care for your body.

Fulfill your calling.

If a tool helps you do that, keep it.

If it quietly turns your attention inward and leaves you more anxious than effective...

Don't be afraid to take it off your wrist.

Sometimes the most optimized life isn't the one with the most dashboards.

It's the one with the most freedom.

More Resources To Help You Optimize

💊 My (Scott's) full supplement regimen