Skip to content
5 min read longevity

What If You're Protecting Yourself From the Wrong Things?

Not all discomfort is bad for you, and not all relief is good for you. Learning to distinguish productive discomfort from harmful stress could change the way you make decisions about your health, relationships, and ministry.

What If You're Protecting Yourself From the Wrong Things?
Photo by Mat Napo / Unsplash

Imagine hiring a personal trainer who gives you the following advice:

"Never lift anything that feels heavy. Your muscles are communicating their boundaries, and you need to respect them."

"If an exercise makes you uncomfortable, eliminate it from your routine."

"And above all, protect your peace. You don't need that kind of resistance in your life."

Congratulations.

You've just hired the world's worst personal trainer.

You'll probably leave every workout feeling wonderful.

You also won't get much stronger.

We understand something about physical fitness that we sometimes forget about life and ministry:

Not all discomfort is bad for you.

In fact, some discomfort is necessary for growth.

But there's another side to that truth.

Too much weight, poor technique, or inadequate recovery can cause injury.

A good trainer doesn't tell you to push through everything.

He knows the difference between resistance that builds strength and stress that causes damage.

And pastors need that same discernment.

The Problem With Feeling Better

We've become pretty good at recognizing things that make us uncomfortable.

Difficult relationships.

Demanding responsibilities.

Unpleasant conversations.

Unfamiliar challenges.

And we've developed a whole vocabulary for getting away from them.

Protect your peace.

Respect your boundaries.

Remove the negativity.

Prioritize yourself.

Now, there's legitimate wisdom behind some of that advice.

But here's the problem.

Feeling better and getting better aren't always the same thing.

Sometimes the quickest way to feel better is to avoid the very thing that would help us grow.

Consider the pastor who needs to have a difficult conversation with a staff member.

He's been putting it off for weeks.

Every time he thinks about it, he feels anxious.

So he postpones it again.

Instant relief!

Unfortunately, the problem is still there.

The staff member hasn't improved.

The frustration is growing.

And the conversation will probably be harder next month.

He successfully reduced his discomfort.

He didn't improve his situation.

That's an important distinction.

Two Ways to Get This Wrong

I see two opposite mistakes we can make.

Mistake #1: Treating productive discomfort like harmful stress.

A pastor avoids a leadership challenge because it feels intimidating.

He abandons a new discipline because it's inconvenient.

He refuses to delegate because teaching someone else takes more effort than doing it himself.

He interprets resistance as a warning to stop.

But sometimes resistance is simply the price of increasing capacity.

Think about learning a new technology.

At first, it's frustrating.

You don't know where anything is.

The buttons have apparently been arranged by someone who hates pastors.

You'd rather return to your familiar routine.

But push through the learning curve, and what once took an hour might eventually take ten minutes.

The discomfort was temporary.

The increased capacity can last for years.

Mistake #2: Treating harmful stress like productive discomfort.

This one is just as dangerous.

A pastor works seven days a week, consistently neglects sleep, ignores his family, and tells himself he's simply being faithful.

Another tolerates mistreatment because he thinks endurance means never establishing boundaries.

Still another keeps adding responsibilities despite obvious signs that his health and effectiveness are deteriorating.

These men aren't necessarily building strength.

They may be consuming it.

You wouldn't expect your muscles to grow if you trained them relentlessly without allowing recovery.

Why would we expect our minds, bodies, and relationships to function differently?

The goal isn't to endure everything.

It's to discern what deserves endurance.

Discomfort Is Information, Not Instruction

Here's the principle I want you to remember:

Discomfort is information, not instruction.

It tells you something deserves attention.

It doesn't automatically tell you whether to stop, continue, or change your approach.

So when something feels difficult, ask yourself three questions.

1. Is this pressure connected to something worth producing?

A difficult conversation might produce a healthier relationship.

Learning a new skill might produce greater effectiveness.

Getting up early to exercise might produce greater physical capacity.

But some pressures produce little beyond exhaustion.

Being perpetually available to everyone isn't automatically noble.

Neither is allowing a dysfunctional situation to continue indefinitely.

Ask what the difficulty is actually accomplishing.

2. Am I adapting or deteriorating?

This may be the most revealing question.

When you began resistance training, a weight that once seemed heavy eventually became manageable.

That's adaptation.

You increased your capacity.

Something similar can happen in leadership.

Conversations that once terrified you become easier.

Decisions become clearer.

Responsibilities that once overwhelmed you become manageable.

But what if the opposite is happening?

You're increasingly exhausted.

Your patience is disappearing.

Your health is declining.

You never feel recovered.

Those patterns deserve attention, not another motivational speech about pushing harder.

One difficult day doesn't tell the whole story.

Look at the trajectory.

3. Am I allowing enough recovery?

Even productive stress becomes destructive when there's too much of it for too long.

Sometimes the answer isn't to eliminate the responsibility.

It's to change the rhythm.

A demanding ministry season may be entirely appropriate.

A demanding ministry life with no recovery built into it is another matter.

You can embrace a challenge without making exhaustion your permanent address.

Jesus Understood Both Sides

James tells us that the testing of our faith produces steadfastness (James 1:2–4).

Difficulty can develop something valuable in us.

But Jesus also told His disciples, "Come away by yourselves to a desolate place and rest a while" (Mark 6:31).

Apparently, rest isn't a failure of commitment.

And hardship isn't automatically evidence that something has gone wrong.

The same Lord who calls us to endure also recognizes our need for rest.

Wisdom is knowing when each response is appropriate.

Before You Walk Away—or Push Through

Here's something practical for this week.

Think about one thing in your life or ministry that you're currently trying to escape because it's uncomfortable.

Maybe it's a conversation.

A discipline.

A leadership responsibility.

A necessary change.

Ask yourself:

Am I avoiding this because it's actually harmful, or because it's simply hard?

Now consider something you're continuing to tolerate.

Maybe an unreasonable expectation, an exhausting schedule, or a relationship that consistently crosses appropriate boundaries.

Ask:

Is this making me stronger, or am I slowly paying for it with my health, relationships, and effectiveness?

Don't confuse immediate relief with genuine recovery.

And don't confuse stubborn endurance with spiritual maturity.

Sometimes the right response is to press in.

Sometimes it's to pull back.

Sometimes it's to walk away.

The optimized pastor doesn't make those decisions based solely on how uncomfortable he feels.

He learns to recognize what the discomfort is producing.

Because you don't get stronger by avoiding every weight.

And you don't get stronger by refusing to put the weights down, either.

Learn the difference.

💡
Ask yourself: "If I implement this strategy, will I be a more optimized pastor?" If YES, then stick around. And please share this with another pastor to help expand our impact!